// you’re reading...

Hire POWER!

Networking 2.0 — Open Letter to LinkedIn (and their competitors)



The simple truth is that I am a raving fan of LinkedIn–I love it.

However…

About 2/3 of the time when I invite someone to connect with me on LinkedIn, they say something like, “Sure. But does anybody really use it?”

Someone else said, “Isn’t that just like a geek dating service for jobs?” Ooh. That one hurt.

But the reality is that people, especially the new college students/grads, are wanting–no, demanding–software that exists for their wants and needs. Martha Irvine from AP said it best, I think:

Generation Raised With Internet Grows Up
CHICAGO, AP, 12/5/2004 — Young people are now the savviest of the tech-savvy, as likely to demand a speedy broadband connection as to download music onto an iPod, or upload digital photos to their Web logs. The Internet has shaped the way they work, relax and even date. [via]

So, I have a network of a bazillion people in LinkedIn right now (some of them I am very close to and I love the tool for it) but many of them just aren’t seeing the value in it that they originally must have expected. So, at my request, they went through all the hassle of registering and creating a password and divulging all their hidden secrets about their life and now we’re “LinkedIn”… but what does that really mean? What does it do for me that nobody else can do, or I can’t do myself?

LinkedIn, how do I know you really, truly care about me? After all, I am not just a faceless number you can count on to promote that you have 4.4 million people in your database. This should be a give-and-take relationship. Right now, it just feels like I am doing all the giving. All my contacts, personal information and gory details about where I’ve worked, what I’ve done and what interests me.

Since it is the time of the year for giving, let me give you some advice on how you can balance out this relationship (you’re welcome).

Some of these ideas are practically free. Others may cost you a few CPU cycles and a few cases of Dr. Pepper. None of them involve Holiday Greeting Cards (thanks, but no-thanks).

Easy Stuff

  • Make it easy for me to display a link to my profile.
    This one should be a no-brainer. I put all my stuff on LinkedIn–let me show it off. Especially all the smart people I know. More than that, I will be 10x more likely to keep my online profile updated if I know people are looking at it. Many people are putting their resumes and bios online. Let me just forward people to LinkedIn, instead.
    BTW, I did find a link to my profile after many days and nights of searching. But, if I didn’t know how to hack URIs and encode HTTP GET request strings, I never would have figured it out.
  • Let me make my profile public–if I want (or, at least to Google)
    I am already on Google. I’d really like my LinkedIn profile to be searchable as well. Now, you must be a LinkedIn member to view profiles. Let me give mine to the world, if I want. People who want to connect with me will join.

Feed Me: Unlock your strangle-hold on my information. Let me have some, too.

  • Allow me to create a list of people I know on my blog/site
    This is like a blogroll, but don’t miss a few important points:

    • The links should give the option of going to the user’s blog or seeing their LinkedIn profile.
    • XFN rel= tags need to be available to me as I define who my contacts are, and how I know them. Then, I want these output in my contact-feed. If you want, read what Shirley Kaiser says about XFN, and this web-presentation about why XFM allows “rediculously easy group forming” (Given at SXSW, 2004 by Tantek elik)
    • While JavaScript will make implementing this easy, it’s not readable by spiders which makes the data useless. Let me get this data via OPML or RSS as well or, heck, remote PHP works, too.
    • If I give you my Blogrolling.com password, will you update my blogroll with the blogs of new contacts I add?
  • RSS feeds/emails of things happening in my network
    When stuff happens to the people in my network, I’d like to know. Allow me to subscribe to a few feeds (contract with Feedblitz to enable feed-to-email service) to know about different things, such as:

    • People that just changed positions/jobs, or added items to their profile
    • New opportunities available
    • New jobs in my personal network
    • Questions being asked by people in my network
    • Events, Trainings, other calendar items from people in my network
    • New blog postings from my trusted contacts
    • New Flickr photos and del.icio.us bookmarks from my trusted contacts

The Holy Grail
If you’re still reading, that’s great. Get to the level I am talking about below, and you’ve got a network everybody on earth will want to be a part of:

Allow me (or third-party companies) to access/change my LinkedIn data via API calls (SOAP/REST, whatever) and ask basic questions to determine intelligent actions based on who I know and how closely I know them. For example:

  • I would love it if my email client collected a (secure) list from you of my trusted connections and their email addresses and used that in it’s spam filtering algorithms. This could prevent both false-positives and unreliable filtering based on content alone. (Partner with gmail/yahoo, etc on this one! Also, SpamAssassin and others should jump at the chance to have a user-defined “whitelist” that requires no programming by the user!)
  • Overlay LinkedIn data from Google Maps/Yahoo Maps, etc, to show me where my contacts live.
  • Let my contacts update LinkedIn with coordinates of where they are right now, enabling offline connections. Many cell-phones are enabling GPS location notification–work with Verizon/Cingular, etc, and allow my cell-phone to tell you where I am on earth right now (if I want)
  • If I give you my Instant Messenger username and password, will you add my new contacts to my buddy list?
  • If someone in my trusted contacts list calls my cell-phone, can you tell me who it is?
  • Can you enable my cellphone/pda to alert me when people I know are close to me –or– give me the ability to browse a list of people I may be in a room with via some notification. For example, everyone who enters a conference room is registered and that list is compared with my LinkedIn database to tell me who of those people I know, and how I know them–or who I should meet.

In summary, here’s my pitch and request: LinkedIn, I love your tool. It’s easy, fresh, kinda fun and it’s an incredibly easy way to actively manage my contacts and relationships. The next step is for LinkedIn to actively help me passively manage my relationships. Help me keep up on things that I may not have known are happening.

The other key here is to strike up relationships that don’t constantly drive subscription fees. Some of these features I think are prime for fees in the right place, and to the right organization. But, please don’t be so concerned about driving revenue that you miss the fact that the value you add to your data will define the revenue you’ll make in the long-run.

  • Visits to your website will go way up when more people are actively using, grooming and managing their contacts via your portal.
  • Subscription deals can be struck with content providers and others to drive incremental revenue streams from data you’re already providing.
    That will enrich their user’s-experience, binding their customers closer to their service, and all of it stems from you opening access to your system.

If you do that for me, LinkedIn will be as valuable to busy professionals as a resume is to job-seekers or a phone-number is to communication.

If you don’t do this, I fear for you that the list of queries matching “better than LinkedIn” will grow very large, very soon.

Good luck, and thanks for the service!

Tags:

Popularity: 20% [?]

Retweet This Post

Discussion

9 comments for “Networking 2.0 — Open Letter to LinkedIn (and their competitors)”

  1. OK, I already found SNARF from a devutah blogger, Eric Ringger at http://eringger.blogspot.com/2005/12/snarf.html:

    SNARF was built around the notion that social network information that is already available to the computer system can be usefully reflected to the user: a message from a manager might be seen differently than a message from a stranger, for example. SNARF applies this idea to email triage: handling the flow of messages when time is short and mail is long.

    We’ve only just begun…

    Posted by Robert Merrill | December 21, 2005, 10:40 am
  2. We’ve received over 10,000 feature suggestions in 2005, so there is no way we can do them all in 2006. But we will try our hardest to provide those that are most useful to the broadest set of our free personal account holders and those that have the highest value to our subscribers. We know some of our users want to use their LinkedIn profile outside of LinkedIn, and we definitely would like to enable that. We also have made API’s available for selected partners (like SimplyHired), and you will be able to use your LinkedIn profile in AIM. Our new Outlook toolbar will allow you to use yourpast correspondence patterns, your connections and the entire LinkedIn network to help prioritize your inbox–without ever leaving Outlook. So, while we probably can’t do everything you’d like to see in 2006, I think you will be pleased overall, and I’m passing your post around to some of the other execs.

    Posted by Konstantin Guericke | December 23, 2005, 10:32 pm
  3. Konstantin,

    The very fact that you’ve replied gives me good feelings. Thanks.

    I am supremely confident that you can tweak just a few things and turn this incredible app into, truly, indispensible to people and their careers.

    Further, with some extra late-nite pizza runs on the house, you could easilly make sure “linkedin” touches peoples lives, literally, every day and in ways nobody imagined.

    For example, I like how XFN allows you to specify if you have actually met the person you’re linking to. And, how/how closely you’re related. I would like to tag my family, for example. Old roommates, co-workers, and people I’ve met only online or by phone should all be classified differently.

    Someone–or a team of them–in your company right now probably has the ideas for LinkedIN’s bridge to the next killer app in social networking.

    How much would that be worth? $10,000? $100,000? More?

    I wonder if you had a contest–internally or externally–to develop the next killer social networking app. Do it a-la the Grand Challenge robotic car races.

    Give a team $50K (and jobs, if they’re not internal to you) to develop the absolute incredible next-gen app in the next 4 months. Setup some rules and see what happens.

    Hey, nothing gets things moving like Geeks at war with eachother!

    Posted by Robert Merrill | December 28, 2005, 6:48 pm
  4. [...] - Does this service have to revolve around cities? - I do think this is a perfect application to layer on top of LinkedIn, by the way [...]

    Posted by Utah Tech Jobs » Dodgeball — Mobile Meetups Made Eay | January 18, 2006, 6:50 am
  5. [...] Networking 2.0 Open Letter to LinkedIn (and their competitors) [...]

    Posted by Robert Merrill » Networking 2.0 — Open Letter to LinkedIn (and their competitors) | May 27, 2007, 10:45 am
  6. [...] away from LinkedIn and closed-wall applications in-general, that it appears they may be actually implementing some of the stuff I complained about 18 months ago. (Via Mashable): LinkedIn is feeling the heat from Facebook’s platform strategy: realizing it [...]

    Posted by Utah Tech Jobs : Blog Archive : LinkedIn Listening? | June 28, 2007, 12:07 pm
  7. [...] to help people get and keep connected.  I am strongly in favor of LinkedIn, and I am glad they made some changes to keep up with the pack… but fear of spam and network abuse has them wielding their swords a [...]

    Posted by Utah Tech Jobs : LinkedIN: ‘I’m Gonna Have to Block You’ | August 30, 2007, 11:33 am
  8. [...] blog post on the subject, including some cool videos. Check it out. It’s been three years since I called LinkedIN out abut missing the boat.  SO MUCH has changed in this marketspace, since then, but I’m glad to see they’re [...]

    Posted by Utah Tech Jobs » LinkedIN Mobile Version now Available | March 20, 2008, 1:44 pm
  9. [...] blog post on the subject, including some cool videos. Check it out. It’s been three years since I called LinkedIN out abut missing the boat. SO MUCH has changed in this marketspace, since then, but I’m glad to see they’re [...]

    Posted by LinkedIN Mobile Version now Available | April 16, 2008, 12:07 pm

Post a comment

CouchCast - Weekly Tech & Business Talk Radio

↑ Grab this Headline Animator